Monday, September 8, 2014

NYT Article Aims to Drum Up Sympathy for Palestinian "Refugees," Shows the Lunacy of Their Permanent Refugee Status Instead

This tug-from-the-heartstrings story appeared in yesterday's paper:
AL FAWWAR, West Bank — Up a rutted alley, mothers in head scarves, seated under flapping cloth canopies, sip tea and weave baskets. They’ve gathered in a dusty, sun-bleached square, not much bigger than a pocket park, made of limestone and concrete, shoehorned into a warren of low, concrete and cinder-block houses. The square isn’t much to look at. 
But, years in the making, it has stirred some profound debates here at this old and deeply conservative Palestinian refugee camp, about hot-button topics like the role of women and the right of return. Along with headline sites like Tahrir Square in Cairo and Gezi Park in Istanbul, it’s another example, small and off the radar, of how even the most unlikely public space can become a testing ground for entrenched political authority and the social status quo.
Public space like the plaza in Al Fawwar is mostly unheard-of in Palestinian camps across the West Bank. Architectural upgrades raise fundamental questions about the Palestinian identity, implying permanence, which refugees here have opposed for generations. The lack of normal amenities, like squares and parks in the camps, commonplace in Palestinian towns and cities in the West Bank, was originally by design: Camps were conceived as temporary quarters. The absence of public space was then preserved over the years to fortify residents’ self-identification as refugees, displaced and stateless. ...
From the river to the sea, they're waiting for "Palestine" to be "free."

Like I said--sheer madness.

This pathological thinking has gone on for so long and is so firmly entrenched in their sense of identity, though, that these "displaced" ones may never figure out that they've been played for chumps and have been suffering for many decades as a direct result.

No comments: